Skip to main content

Nicholtown Homes for Sale with In-Town Trail Access

Nicholtown stands out as one of Greenville's most walkable and rapidly evolving neighborhoods, where historic character meets modern urban living just minutes from Downtown.

Active
7
Recently Sold
48+

Active & Pending Listings

About Nicholtown

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Nicholtown, Greenville

Nicholtown stands out as one of Greenville's most walkable and rapidly evolving neighborhoods, where historic character meets modern urban living just minutes from Downtown. This historically significant community has emerged as a destination for buyers seeking authentic in-town living with direct access to the city's premier amenities.

Community Highlights

"Steps from the Swamp Rabbit Trail with Cleveland Park, Downtown Greenville, and Holland Park all within walking or biking distance"

Location defines Nicholtown's appeal. The community provides immediate access to the Swamp Rabbit Trail via multiple entry points, including the Baxter Street access and nearby Sliding Rock Creek Trail. Cleveland Park, the Greenville Zoo, and Holland Park sit within a comfortable walk, while Downtown Greenville's dining, entertainment, and cultural attractions are less than two miles away. Easy access to I-385 and Laurens Road adds commuting convenience without sacrificing the walkable lifestyle.

The neighborhood showcases a compelling mix of architectural periods. Historic homes from the 1940s-1960s have been thoughtfully renovated with modern kitchens featuring granite countertops, stainless appliances, and luxury vinyl plank flooring, while preserving original hardwood floors and character details. New construction from 2017-2025 introduces Craftsman-style homes with open floor plans, site-laid hardwood floors, 9-foot ceilings, main-level primary suites, and covered front porches that honor traditional neighborhood design principles.

Amenities & Lifestyle

Nicholtown benefits from an active Nicholtown Neighborhood Association that operates a Tool Lending Library and Community Garden. A newly renovated Community Center is currently under construction, further strengthening the neighborhood's social infrastructure. With no mandatory HOA but optional neighborhood association membership, residents enjoy community benefits without restrictive covenants.

Location & Schools

The neighborhood is zoned for Brook Glenn Elementary, Northwood Middle, and Wade Hampton High School. Lots range from compact urban parcels around 5,227 square feet to generous properties exceeding 2.8 acres, with mature trees providing natural privacy on many sites.

Questions about Nicholtown?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Greenville

Ask about Nicholtown — we answer fast

Own a home in Nicholtown?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Nicholtown sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Nicholtown

Recently Sold in Nicholtown Showing 1-48+ recently sold in Nicholtown, Greenville with dates and property details

Recently Sold

Showing 1-48+ recently sold in Nicholtown, Greenville

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
320 Ackley Road sold home in Greenville, SC 320 Ackley Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 18 2026 $380,000 135 1,239 sq ft 100.0% $307
11 Baxter Street sold home in Greenville, SC 11 Baxter Street 2 bd · 1 ba Jun 18 2026 $315,000 68 963 sq ft 98.5% $327
12 Harris Lane sold home in Greenville, SC 12 Harris Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 15 2026 $424,607 51 1,460 sq ft 100.0% $291
102 Hilton Street sold home in Greenville, SC 102 Hilton Street 3 bd · 2 ba May 15 2026 $490,000 48 1,879 sq ft 101.0% $261
25 Mims Avenue sold home in Greenville, SC 25 Mims Avenue 3 bd · 2 ba May 13 2026 $315,000 158 1,371 sq ft 84.0% $230
101 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 101 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Apr 24 2026 $405,000 70 1,721 sq ft 97.6% $235
120 Clark Street sold home in Greenville, SC 120 Clark Street 4 bd · 2 ba Apr 20 2026 $640,000 178 2,165 sq ft 91.6% $296
321 Ackley Road sold home in Greenville, SC 321 Ackley Road 3 bd · 2 ba Apr 16 2026 $390,000 155 1,806 sq ft 91.8% $216
109 Rebecca Street sold home in Greenville, SC 109 Rebecca Street 3 bd · 2 ba Apr 1 2026 $270,000 197 1,040 sq ft 100.0% $260
6 Brush Street sold home in Greenville, SC 6 Brush Street 3 bd · 2 ba Mar 27 2026 $405,000 51 1,544 sq ft 97.6% $262
105 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 105 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Mar 23 2026 $374,900 58 1,420 sq ft 100.0% $264
14 Chaney Street sold home in Greenville, SC 14 Chaney Street 3 bd · 2 ba Mar 10 2026 $315,000 53 1,362 sq ft 100.0% $231
226 Cowan Court sold home in Greenville, SC 226 Cowan Court 3 bd · 2 ba Feb 6 2026 $425,000 172 1,980 sq ft 95.1% $215
6 Lark Street sold home in Greenville, SC 6 Lark Street 2 bd · 1 ba Jan 12 2026 $155,000 32 764 sq ft 88.6% $203
16 Miller Street sold home in Greenville, SC 16 Miller Street 3 bd · 1 ba Jan 9 2026 $270,000 110 878 sq ft 93.1% $308
31 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 31 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Jan 5 2026 $409,000 51 1,693 sq ft 100.0% $242
12 Bridwell Avenue sold home in Greenville, SC 12 Bridwell Avenue 3 bd · 2 ba Dec 30 2025 $425,000 93 1,948 sq ft 94.5% $218
9 Virnelle Street sold home in Greenville, SC 9 Virnelle Street 2 bd · 2 ba Dec 5 2025 $385,000 58 1,207 sq ft 97.5% $319
109 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 109 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 6 2025 $430,000 33 1,672 sq ft 100.0% $257
108 Arden Street Extension sold home in Greenville, SC 108 Arden Street Extension 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 4 2025 $429,500 76 1,502 sq ft 100.0% $286
0 Palm Street Lot 703 sold home in Greenville, SC 0 Palm Street Lot 703 Oct 22 2025 $240,000 206 126.6%
332 Ackley Road sold home in Greenville, SC 332 Ackley Road 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 29 2025 $407,500 50 1,519 sq ft 101.9% $268
8 Harris Lane sold home in Greenville, SC 8 Harris Lane 3 bd · 1 ba Jul 28 2025 $256,000 51 921 sq ft 97.3% $278
6 Hendricks Street sold home in Greenville, SC 6 Hendricks Street 4 bd · 3 ba Jun 16 2025 $625,000 73 2,500 sq ft 100.0% $250
112 Arden St Extension sold home in Greenville, SC 112 Arden St Extension 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 16 2025 $390,000 58 1,227 sq ft 97.5% $318
14 Carter Street sold home in Greenville, SC 14 Carter Street 3 bd · 1 ba May 21 2025 $315,000 41 1,060 sq ft 95.5% $297
9 Merlocke Drive sold home in Greenville, SC 9 Merlocke Drive 3 bd · 2 ba May 13 2025 $429,000 80 1,535 sq ft 100.0% $279
23 Bridwell Avenue sold home in Greenville, SC 23 Bridwell Avenue 3 bd · 1 ba Apr 16 2025 $253,000 47 1,016 sq ft 92.0% $249
211 Ludlow Street sold home in Greenville, SC 211 Ludlow Street 2 bd · 1 ba Mar 25 2025 $295,000 96 871 sq ft 93.7% $339
115 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 115 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Mar 13 2025 $350,000 100 1,429 sq ft 99.0% $245
4 Chaney Street sold home in Greenville, SC 4 Chaney Street 2 bd · 2 ba Mar 13 2025 $334,500 22 1,314 sq ft 98.7% $255
320 Elder Street Extension sold home in Greenville, SC 320 Elder Street Extension 3 bd · 1 ba Feb 28 2025 $190,000 119 1,225 sq ft 95.5% $155
30 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 30 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Feb 24 2025 $416,000 50 1,880 sq ft 100.2% $221
119 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 119 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Feb 12 2025 $360,000 60 1,429 sq ft 98.5% $252
13 Miller Street sold home in Greenville, SC 13 Miller Street 3 bd · 2 ba Jan 17 2025 $370,000 98 1,339 sq ft 97.4% $276
2 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 2 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Dec 12 2024 $390,000 42 1,204 sq ft 99.1% $324
15 Miller Street sold home in Greenville, SC 15 Miller Street 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 12 2024 $393,700 51 1,378 sq ft 101.0% $286
101 Tuskegee Avenue sold home in Greenville, SC 101 Tuskegee Avenue 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 8 2024 $360,000 167 1,132 sq ft 96.0% $318
10 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 10 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 23 2024 $398,000 32 1,774 sq ft 100.0% $224
14 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 14 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 22 2024 $378,000 69 1,616 sq ft 96.9% $234
18 Celand Street sold home in Greenville, SC 18 Celand Street 2 bd · 2 ba Oct 9 2024 $423,000 53 1,140 sq ft 98.4% $371
16 Zara Street sold home in Greenville, SC 16 Zara Street 3 bd · 1 ba Oct 8 2024 $260,000 32 1,101 sq ft 96.7% $236
5 Haley Court sold home in Greenville, SC 5 Haley Court 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 29 2024 $371,000 44 1,150 sq ft 98.9% $323
6 Bridwell Avenue sold home in Greenville, SC 6 Bridwell Avenue 2 bd · 1 ba Jun 28 2024 $159,900 40 547 sq ft 106.7% $292
218 Nichol Street sold home in Greenville, SC 218 Nichol Street 2 bd · 1 ba Jun 27 2024 $200,000 35 1,024 sq ft 61.5% $195
13 Chaney Street sold home in Greenville, SC 13 Chaney Street 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 13 2024 $345,000 108 1,200 sq ft 97.2% $288
109 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 109 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 13 2024 $392,876 44 1,630 sq ft 100.6% $241
110 Joseph Mathis Way sold home in Greenville, SC 110 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bd · 2 ba May 22 2024 $400,000 22 1,570 sq ft 99.8% $255

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Nicholtown, Greenville

Median sale price · trailing 12 mo
$390,000
23 sales closed · Jul 2025 – Jun 2026
1 yr ▴ 5.3% 3 yr ▴ 13.5% Greenville 1 yr ▴ 7.1%

Nicholtown median sale price is $390,000, up 5.3% from a year ago; Greenville is up 7.1%.

+3 outside price range.

The Nicholtown real estate market shows balanced market conditions. Homes typically sell within 59 days. With 6 active listings and 23 homes sold in the past year, a healthy balance exists between buyers and sellers.

Pricing

Median Price
$427,000
Average Price
$432,133
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$242
1-Yr Price Trend
+6.8%

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
2.8
Avg Bathrooms
1.7
Avg Lot Size
0.18 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
6
Sold Last Year
23
Median Days to Sell
59 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
2019
New Construction
4%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Nicholtown, Greenville

5 properties
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Nicholtown. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.