Sugarmill Homes for Sale with Pool and Tennis

Sugarmill stands out on Greenville's Eastside for its roomy lots, brick-heavy traditional homes, and amenity core built around a neighborhood pool, clubhouse, and tennis-pickleball courts. The neighborhood's identity centers on flexible floor plans, outdoor living space, and quick access to the Greer-Greenville corridor.

Community Highlights

Most recorded homes in Sugarmill were built between 1986 and 1999, with the strongest concentration from the late 1980s through the mid-1990s. Brick is a common exterior finish here, though siding and some stone accents also appear. Traditional two-story layouts lead the mix, and four- and five-bedroom plans are common. Fireplaces, formal dining rooms, built-ins, hardwood floors, bonus rooms, and dedicated office or flex space recur throughout the neighborhood, while screened porches, decks, and patios extend the living space outdoors. Lots are another part of the appeal: recorded homes range from roughly 11,325 to 25,264 square feet, with a typical lot around 14,374 square feet, giving many properties fenced back yards, mature landscaping, and more breathing room than newer subdivisions often offer.

Basements appear in roughly a quarter of recorded homes and usually accompany some of the neighborhood's larger, higher-priced properties. S Ticonderoga Drive in particular shows one of the clearest price premiums inside Sugarmill, reflecting a pocket where larger homes and upgraded finishes tend to command more.

Amenities & Lifestyle

Sugarmill's shared amenities are one of its clearest identity markers. Many homes reference a clubhouse, neighborhood swimming pool, tennis courts, and pickleball, with some also calling out sidewalks and streetlights for internal walks through the subdivision. Private outdoor setups matter here too: fenced yards, mature trees, oversized cul-de-sac lots, and entertaining features such as outdoor kitchens, fire features, workshops, and side-entry garages appear often enough to feel characteristic rather than incidental.

Location & Schools

The neighborhood sits near the Eastside/Pelham Road corridor at roughly 34.8825, -82.2586, giving it convenient access to shopping, dining, medical offices, I-85, and GSP International Airport. Homes here are commonly zoned for Buena Vista Elementary, Riverside Middle, and Riverside High. Taken together, Sugarmill reads as a larger-lot Eastside neighborhood where traditional architecture, practical square footage, and a strong amenity package still define the address.