Skip to main content

Turkey Pen Gap Homes for Sale in Horse Shoe, SC

Turkey Pen Gap in Horse Shoe feels like a tucked-away mountain corridor where the setting does a lot of the talking.

Active
1
Pending
1
Recently Sold
15

Active & Pending Listings

About Turkey Pen Gap

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Turkey Pen Gap, Horse Shoe

First Impressions

Turkey Pen Gap in Horse Shoe feels like a tucked-away mountain corridor where the setting does a lot of the talking. Homes here sit on level or gently usable lots, and several listings highlight Boylston Creek as a backdrop, giving the neighborhood a distinctly natural, creekside character. The overall impression is practical and unpolished in the best way: places to park, room for gear, and easy access to the outdoors.

"A creekside mountain setting with everyday convenience built right in."

Home Styles & Community Feel

The housing mix leans heavily toward single-family residences and manufactured homes, with newer examples appearing alongside older homes and land parcels. Many properties emphasize open split-bedroom layouts, covered porches or decks, and outbuildings or sheds that add useful storage. Lot sizes are often generous for the price point, and the terrain is typically level, which makes outdoor space feel more usable than decorative. You’ll also see a practical streak in the finishes: updated roofs, newer HVAC systems, and move-in-ready interiors show up often enough to define the tone of the community.

The feel is straightforward and rural rather than manicured. Some homes sit near the end of the road or on private wooded lots, while others are set up for easy access with driveways, parking, and space for hobbies or equipment. Creek views, mountain views, and wooded edges give the area a relaxed western North Carolina backdrop.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Daily life here is shaped by convenience to the region’s outdoor and travel hubs. Listings point to nearby trails, waterfalls, and the Turkey Pen Gap Trailhead, while also noting quick access to restaurants, grocery stores, breweries, and the outlet malls. Asheville Regional Airport is close enough for easy regional travel, and the drive to downtown Brevard or downtown Hendersonville is short enough to keep errands and dining practical without giving up the mountain setting.

"Close to trailheads, shopping, and mountain-town errands, yet still rooted in a creekside setting."

Location & Schools

Turkey Pen Gap sits in Horse Shoe along the Turkey Pen Gap Road and Hwy 280 corridor, in the Transylvania County area near the Henderson County line. Public remarks place Asheville Regional Airport about 15 minutes away, downtown Brevard about 15 to 20 minutes away, and downtown Hendersonville about 20 minutes away. The community is also described as convenient to Mills River, Asheville, and the Blue Ridge Parkway, with Jump Off Rock and Dupont State Recreational Forest among the nearby recreation draws. School assignments are not specified in the MLS material, so the local school names remain unspecified here.

Questions about Turkey Pen Gap?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Horse Shoe

Ask about Turkey Pen Gap — we answer fast

Own a home in Turkey Pen Gap?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Turkey Pen Gap sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Turkey Pen Gap

Recently Sold in Turkey Pen Gap 15 recently sold in Turkey Pen Gap, Horse Shoe with dates and property details

Recently Sold

15 recently sold in Turkey Pen Gap, Horse Shoe

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
624 586 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 624 586 Turkey Pen Gap Road Feb 13 2026 $115,000 56 92.0%
946 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 946 Turkey Pen Gap Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jan 8 2026 $245,000 182 1,404 sq ft 96.1% $175
166 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 166 Turkey Pen Gap Road 3 bd · 2 ba Sep 17 2025 $75,000 252 1,782 sq ft 83.3% $42
800 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 800 Turkey Pen Gap Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 30 2025 $200,000 43 1,515 sq ft 101.5% $132
90 Gobbler Circle sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 90 Gobbler Circle 3 bd · 2 ba Dec 21 2022 $233,000 58 1,620 sq ft 102.4% $144
221 Turkey Pen Gap Road C4 sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 221 Turkey Pen Gap Road C4 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 15 2022 $240,000 42 1,475 sq ft 102.1% $163
292 Gobbler Circle 16 sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 292 Gobbler Circle 16 Aug 25 2022 $45,000 98 90.9%
221 Turkey Pen Gap Road lot 4 / C4 sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 221 Turkey Pen Gap Road lot 4 / C4 Apr 7 2021 $28,000 15 112.0%
24 Roost Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 24 Roost Road 4 bd · 2 ba Sep 21 2018 $150,000 73 2,128 sq ft 100.0% $70
154 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 154 Turkey Pen Gap Road 3 bd · 2 ba Sep 7 2018 $146,000 111 1,512 sq ft 97.4% $97
958 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 958 Turkey Pen Gap Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 22 2018 $128,000 45 1,539 sq ft 98.5% $83
15a Turkey Pen Gap sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 15a Turkey Pen Gap 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 5 2015 $63,000 66 1,200 sq ft 96.9% $53
339 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 339 Turkey Pen Gap Road 3 bd · 2 ba Dec 11 2014 $70,000 65 1,488 sq ft 78.2% $47
166 Turkey Pen Gap Road sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 166 Turkey Pen Gap Road 1 bd · 2 ba Aug 12 2013 $38,000 125 1,796 sq ft 83.5% $21
96 Turkey Pen Gap Lane sold home in Horse Shoe, SC 96 Turkey Pen Gap Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Sep 27 2012 $110,000 251 1,296 sq ft 91.7% $85

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Turkey Pen Gap, Horse Shoe

Horse Shoe 1 yr ▾ 27.1%

Below trend-line threshold — city median shown for context

$200k $400k $600k 20222023202420252026 $445k Horse Shoe Sales closed per quarter peak 2

The Turkey Pen Gap real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 66 days. With 2 active listings and 4 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price
$249,500
Average Price
$249,500
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$51

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
2.9
Avg Bathrooms
2.0
Avg Lot Size
0.69 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
2
Sold Last Year
4
Median Days to Sell
66 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
1997
New Construction
0%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Turkey Pen Gap, Horse Shoe

1 property
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Turkey Pen Gap. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.