Skip to main content

Settlers Cove Homes in Mars Hill with Mountain Views

Settlers Cove in Mars Hill feels like a mountain community with a clear point of view: polished, private, and shaped around long-range scenery.

Active
17
Recently Sold
33

Active & Pending Listings

View all 17 on the map →

About Settlers Cove

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Settlers Cove, Mars Hill

First Impressions

Settlers Cove in Mars Hill feels like a mountain community with a clear point of view: polished, private, and shaped around long-range scenery. The approach along Gabriels Creek Road and into the neighborhood sets up that mood well, with rolling countryside, wooded edges, and an elevated setting just outside town. Gated entry, paved roads, underground utilities, and fiber internet give the subdivision a finished infrastructure, while mature hardwoods and open views keep the landscape unmistakably Western North Carolina. It is a place where the setting does a lot of the talking.

Home Styles & Community Feel

The community is a blend of build-ready lots and custom homes, so the streets have an interesting rhythm. Some properties are cleared, level, and already prepared for construction, while others showcase newer residences with modern farmhouse, Craftsman, contemporary, and mountain-inspired design. Inside the homes, common themes include open layouts, vaulted ceilings, fireplaces, large windows, screened or covered porches, and well-planned kitchens. Garages appear often, and basements are also a meaningful part of the housing mix, adding flexibility for extra living space or storage.

The land itself is a major part of the appeal. Many parcels are a little over an acre, with gentle topography that makes building more approachable than on steeper mountain ground. Corner lots, paved frontage, and broad building sites are common, and the community’s covenants and architectural review process help maintain a cohesive look as custom homes and vacant lots continue to share the same streets.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Settlers Cove is built around ease rather than a long list of resort-style features. The wooded setting also brings a strong natural backdrop, and listing remarks frequently mention deer, turkey, and the privacy that comes from the surrounding trees.

Day-to-day errands naturally center on Mars Hill, where groceries, restaurants, banks, coffee shops, and medical services are close at hand. Mars Hill University adds a steady local presence, and the town’s events and college atmosphere give the area a little extra energy. For larger outings, Asheville is an easy drive, and outdoor recreation such as rafting and skiing is within reach as well.

Location & Schools

Settlers Cove sits in the Mars Hill / Gabriels Creek Road area of the Blue Ridge Mountains in western North Carolina. I-26 is about 3 miles away in one listing, downtown Mars Hill is typically 5 to 10 minutes from the neighborhood, and Mars Hill University is also about 5 minutes away. Asheville is usually described as a 20 to 25 minute drive, while Weaverville is about 15 minutes by I-26. Nearby destinations mentioned in listings include downtown Mars Hill, Mars Hill University, local groceries, restaurants, banks, coffee shops, a medical clinic, the new AdventHealth Hospital in Weaverville slated for 2026, and Wolf Laurel Ski Resort. School assignments are commonly listed as Mars Hill Elementary, Madison Middle, and Madison High, which fits the community’s practical mountain-town location profile.

Questions about Settlers Cove?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Mars Hill

Ask about Settlers Cove — we answer fast

Own a home in Settlers Cove?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Settlers Cove sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Settlers Cove

Recently Sold in Settlers Cove 33 recently sold in Settlers Cove, Mars Hill with dates and property details

Recently Sold

33 recently sold in Settlers Cove, Mars Hill

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
9999 Gabriels Creek Road sold home in Mars Hill, SC 9999 Gabriels Creek Road Mar 26 2026 $85,000 274 94.4%
9999 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 9999 Settlers Trail Dec 12 2025 $85,000 170 100.0%
9999 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 9999 Settlers Trail Sep 18 2025 $80,000 84 100.0%
00 Settlers Trail Settlers Trail 16&17 sold home in Mars Hill, SC 00 Settlers Trail Settlers Trail 16&17 May 17 2024 $160,000 66 100.0%
Lot 20 Settlers Trail None sold home in Mars Hill, SC Lot 20 Settlers Trail None Aug 24 2023 $42,500 34 100.0%
660 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 660 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 4 ba Apr 17 2023 $750,000 47 3,771 sq ft 100.0% $199
999 Settlers Trail 21 sold home in Mars Hill, SC 999 Settlers Trail 21 Apr 10 2023 $51,000 63 85.1%
735 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 735 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 4 ba Mar 22 2023 $690,000 63 4,599 sq ft 94.5% $150
712 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 712 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 4 ba Aug 9 2022 $775,000 85 3,445 sq ft 97.0% $225
845 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 845 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 3 ba Mar 30 2022 $739,000 27 4,318 sq ft 98.5% $171
9999 Settlers Trail 35 sold home in Mars Hill, SC 9999 Settlers Trail 35 Jan 4 2022 $5,000 84 100.0%
Lot 18 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC Lot 18 Settlers Trail Nov 2 2021 $38,500 880 81.1%
280 Settlers Trail Trail 34 sold home in Mars Hill, SC 280 Settlers Trail Trail 34 4 bd · 3 ba Oct 19 2021 $575,000 110 3,946 sq ft 92.0% $146
712 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 712 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 4 ba Sep 22 2021 $675,000 63 3,150 sq ft 93.1% $214
Lot 21 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC Lot 21 Settlers Trail Mar 19 2021 $55,000 51 100.0%
Lot 4 Lot 5 Settlers Trail 4 & 5 sold home in Mars Hill, SC Lot 4 Lot 5 Settlers Trail 4 & 5 Jan 15 2021 $80,000 1107 81.6%
9999 Settlers Trail 6 sold home in Mars Hill, SC 9999 Settlers Trail 6 Jan 15 2021 $36,000 966 80.0%
51 Pioneer Way sold home in Mars Hill, SC 51 Pioneer Way 4 bd · 4 ba Jan 14 2021 $575,000 47 4,708 sq ft 100.0% $122
735 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 735 Settlers Trail 5 bd · 4 ba Dec 9 2020 $541,665 378 4,599 sq ft 93.8% $118
645 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 645 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 4 ba Jun 15 2020 $563,000 111 4,511 sq ft 97.7% $125
239 Peddlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 239 Peddlers Trail 4 bd · 3 ba May 27 2020 $520,215 186 4,601 sq ft 100.1% $113
767 Settlers Trail Trail 11 sold home in Mars Hill, SC 767 Settlers Trail Trail 11 4 bd · 4 ba Jan 8 2018 $365,000 68 2,979 sq ft 100.0% $123
845 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 845 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 2 ba Aug 31 2017 $470,000 80 4,560 sq ft 96.9% $103
735 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 735 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 3 ba Jun 27 2017 $392,000 119 2,969 sq ft 98.0% $132
81 Pioneer Way sold home in Mars Hill, SC 81 Pioneer Way 4 bd · 4 ba Apr 5 2017 $454,000 327 5,247 sq ft 95.7% $87
51 Pioneer Way sold home in Mars Hill, SC 51 Pioneer Way 4 bd · 4 ba Dec 2 2016 $420,000 498 4,486 sq ft 96.7% $94
239 Peddlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 239 Peddlers Trail 4 bd · 3 ba May 24 2016 $440,000 212 4,601 sq ft 97.8% $96
248 Peddlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 248 Peddlers Trail 3 bd · 3 ba May 23 2016 $430,000 62 3,496 sq ft 90.5% $123
Lot 3 Pioneer Way sold home in Mars Hill, SC Lot 3 Pioneer Way Dec 3 2015 $33,500 133 89.3%
675 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 675 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 4 ba Dec 5 2013 $615,000 84 5,151 sq ft 94.6% $119
19 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 19 Settlers Trail Nov 29 2013 $13,000 151 87.2%
280 Settlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 280 Settlers Trail 4 bd · 3 ba Mar 29 2013 $284,500 107 3,937 sq ft 103.6% $72
239 Peddlers Trail sold home in Mars Hill, SC 239 Peddlers Trail 3 bd · 3 ba Mar 8 2013 $439,000 361 4,959 sq ft 94.4% $89

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Settlers Cove, Mars Hill

Median sale price · trailing 12 mo
$675,000
5 sales closed · Sep 2021 – Aug 2022
1 yr ▴ 743.8% Mars Hill 1 yr ▴ 10.0%

Settlers Cove median sale price is $675,000, up 743.8% from a year ago; Mars Hill is up 10.0%.

+3 outside price range.

$200k $400k $600k 20222023202420252026 $675k Settlers Cove$385k Mars Hill Sales closed per quarter peak 2

The Settlers Cove real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 107 days. With 11 active listings and 3 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price
$90,000
Average Price
$348,182
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$101

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
3.8
Avg Bathrooms
3.3
Avg Lot Size
1.85 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
11
Sold Last Year
3
Median Days to Sell
107 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
2009
New Construction
17%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Settlers Cove, Mars Hill

7 properties
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Settlers Cove. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.