Skip to main content

Pisgah Shadows Homes for Sale in Penrose, SC

Pisgah Shadows feels tucked into the mountain landscape in a way that immediately sets the tone: wooded surroundings, long-range views, and a sense of space that comes from larger lots and homes set back from the road.

Pending
2
Recently Sold
8

Active & Pending Listings

About Pisgah Shadows

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Pisgah Shadows, Penrose

First Impressions

Pisgah Shadows feels tucked into the mountain landscape in a way that immediately sets the tone: wooded surroundings, long-range views, and a sense of space that comes from larger lots and homes set back from the road. The community’s character is shaped by Top Of The Mountain Road and Pisgah Shadows Road, with properties that lean into privacy, natural scenery, and a slower mountain rhythm. Several homes are positioned to take advantage of winter views, and the setting between Hendersonville and Brevard gives the neighborhood a distinctly Western North Carolina feel.

"A wooded hillside setting with room to breathe and views that open up with the seasons."

Home Styles & Community Feel

The housing here is primarily single-family, with a mix of classic mountain cabins, ranch-style homes, and newer custom or pre-construction designs. Older homes date back to the early 1960s, while the newest example reaches into 2027, so the neighborhood spans multiple eras of mountain living. Many homes feature open floor plans, porches, fireplaces, and flexible bonus spaces, while others lean into workshop-ready garages, lofts, or basement levels. Lot sizes are generous, averaging about 1.47 acres, which helps reinforce the spacious, retreat-like feel.

The architectural palette is varied rather than uniform. You’ll see rustic touches like tongue-and-groove ceilings, wood stoves, and screened porches alongside more contemporary finishes such as quartz counters and modern Craftsman styling. That blend gives Pisgah Shadows a lived-in, custom feel rather than a tightly packaged subdivision look.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Daily life here is defined less by formal amenities and more by the landscape itself. Mature woods, landscaped paths, garden beds, sheds, carports, and detached garages show up frequently, and several homes are designed to make the most of outdoor living. The neighborhood’s rhythm is shaped by mountain views, quiet gravel roads, and easy access to recreation rather than clubhouse-style features. With no waterfront presence and no pool pattern in the listings, the appeal stays centered on land, privacy, and the ability to shape the property to fit personal use.

"This is a place for porches, workshop space, and long views rather than shared amenities."

Location & Schools

Pisgah Shadows sits in the Penrose area between Hendersonville and Brevard, with public remarks also pointing to quick access toward Asheville. The setting is especially appealing for anyone who wants to stay close to major outdoor destinations: Dupont State Forest is about 10 minutes away, Pisgah National Forest is also about 10 minutes away, and French Broad River access is roughly 5 minutes from some homes. Downtown Brevard and Hendersonville are both referenced as being within an easy drive, while Asheville is described as readily accessible.

School assignments in the community are listed as Brevard for both middle and high school, with the elementary assignment unspecified in the provided records. That combination, along with the area’s mountain-road setting and proximity to recreation, gives Pisgah Shadows a distinctly regional feel that is grounded in the natural landscape and the nearby towns that anchor daily errands.

Questions about Pisgah Shadows?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Penrose

Ask about Pisgah Shadows — we answer fast

Own a home in Pisgah Shadows?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Pisgah Shadows sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Pisgah Shadows

Recently Sold in Pisgah Shadows 8 recently sold in Pisgah Shadows, Penrose with dates and property details

Recently Sold

8 recently sold in Pisgah Shadows, Penrose

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
184 Pisgah Shadows Road sold home in Penrose, SC 184 Pisgah Shadows Road 2 bd · 2 ba Mar 25 2026 $430,000 135 1,410 sq ft 95.6% $305
73 Top Of The Mountain Road sold home in Penrose, SC 73 Top Of The Mountain Road 2 bd · 2 ba Jan 13 2026 $320,000 56 1,039 sq ft 101.6% $308
8 Priscilla Lane sold home in Penrose, SC 8 Priscilla Lane 2 bd · 3 ba Mar 11 2025 $625,000 38 2,399 sq ft 100.0% $261
9 Shuford Mountain Road sold home in Penrose, SC 9 Shuford Mountain Road 2 bd · 2 ba Sep 8 2023 $467,500 52 1,779 sq ft 95.4% $263
340 Top Of The Mountain Road sold home in Penrose, SC 340 Top Of The Mountain Road 1 bd · 1 ba Oct 7 2016 $160,000 64 1,002 sq ft 91.5% $160
560 Pisgah Shadows Road sold home in Penrose, SC 560 Pisgah Shadows Road 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 30 2014 $134,000 96 1,265 sq ft 100.0% $106
184 Pisgah Shadows Rd sold home in Penrose, SC 184 Pisgah Shadows Rd 2 bd · 2 ba Aug 23 2013 $167,000 112 1,487 sq ft 98.8% $112
404 Top Of The Mountain Road sold home in Penrose, SC 404 Top Of The Mountain Road 3 bd · 4 ba Jun 27 2012 $275,000 332 2,500 sq ft 94.8% $110

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Pisgah Shadows, Penrose

Penrose 1 yr ▾ 29.7%

Below trend-line threshold — city median shown for context

$300k $400k $500k $600k 20222023202420252026 $320k Penrose Sales closed per quarter peak 2

The Pisgah Shadows real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 80 days. With 2 active listings and 2 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price
$255,000
Average Price
$255,000
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$112
1-Yr Price Trend
−40.0%

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
2.3
Avg Bathrooms
2.2
Avg Lot Size
1.88 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
2
Sold Last Year
2
Median Days to Sell
80 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
1985
New Construction
0%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Pisgah Shadows, Penrose

1 property
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Pisgah Shadows. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.